Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

Sunday, January 30, 2022

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - The End

At some point I stopped blogging about this project, as I had fallen behind in writing up what I was listening to, and then I would have to go back and listen to them again. Which was enjoyable, but time-consuming.

I am not used to finishing the big projects I start, which is why I'm happy - but also sad - to have finally finished listening to all the Beatles solo albums in chronological order*.
 
I have listened to many a fantastic album, and some terrible albums, and some just not-so good albums, but it was a journey worth taking. It's been a parallel journey to my own my entire life, though I was only paying attention to it periodically.
 
What have I learned? I'm astounded by people who still say John or George are their favorite solo Beatles. Though they all have produced impressive work, Paul has produced almost five times as much material as John did in his life, almost four times as much as George produced. By sheer volume alone, Paul is unmatched, but add the dazzling quality of RAM, Band on the Run, Flaming Pie, and New on top of all that, and be staggered by the sheer awesomeness of it all.
 
And I've learned that Paul in particular never runs out of contributions to make to us. At the age of 79 - 79! - he produced McCartney 3. And, while much of it is admittedly self-indulgent, and his voice is obviously weak from age, the song "Women and Wives" is, at least, a worthy addition to his catalog. Then he encouraged young people to remix this weak album as McCartney 3 Imagined and they actually managed to make it weaker, telling me that the younger generations *still* aren't ready for Paul to hand the baton off to them yet.
 
And Ringo, poor Ringo, with a bum rap for so long, has produced some fantastic albums, long since the days of Good Night Vienna. Time Takes Time, Ringo Rama, and Zoom In are all things you need to hear if you haven't already. His last EP, the very last thing I listened to for this project, was Change the World. And, boy, did they ever. Interestingly, as if anticipating this might be his last album, he brings us full circle at the end - no, not back to "Love Me Do", but to a cover of "Rock Around the Clock." This has been a time-bending trip across the entirety of all of rock n' roll. The solo Beatles have been my Virgil, leading me to Paradise. Thanks, guys.
 
(*"All" albums means all albums with new material or new arrangements on them. I did skip some of the best of and concert albums.)


...No, I'm not done yet. I was thinking about the rhetorical ending I tossed in at the last moment and realized it was a more apt metaphor for the project than I'd at first considered it to be. Dante's Divine Comedy has some interesting parallels to my listening project.

I started my journey, like with the Inferno, by listening to John and Yoko's experimental albums. If there's an Afterlife where bad people are punished, they are made to listen to Yoko Ono there.

And there are periods of Purgatorio I heard too. George, when he just didn't care anymore and churned out albums like Gone Troppo. Ringo and Paul both went through dry periods where they had trouble finding a way to reconnect to their audience.

And there is Paradiso - not as an end goal, though, to be reached. My Paradise are the moments you pass through where everything is perfect. Being emotionally swept up in the powerful early tracks on All Things Must Pass. Listening to RAM for flaws and finding none. Feeling joy for Ringo when he clearly got his groove back on Time Takes Time. Hearing John happy and just having fun on Rock n’ Roll.

Monday, September 13, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - part 14

At the end of 2001, completely off my Radar at the time and ever since until now, was Paul McCartney's Driving Rain album. It had been three years since Linda died and Paul had already done Run Devil Run, a fun album that sounded nothing like a grieving man, but here Paul allows himself to sound sober and somber, like it was time to outgrow "silly love songs" and move on to more serious rock n' roll. Unfortunately, that meant that none of these songs were very fun, and for a Paul song that tends to mean they won't be very memorable -- and they aren't. I thought "Spinning on an Axis" and "About You" were pretty good as I was listening to them, but I already can't tell you a thing about them anymore. The CD came with a bonus track, "Freedom", which was a much better single. It's a post-9/11 anthem, upbeat, simple, but powerful, and completely different from the rest of the album.

Which brings us back to Ringo and His New All-Starr Band (King Biscuit Flower Hour). By now, these concert albums are all starting to sound pretty much alike even when the band members change; Ringo is certainly sticking to crowd-pleasers and no deep cuts from his repertoire. That said, the "Photograph" and "Back Off Boogaloo" versions we get here are heavier rock than we've been used to hearing. It's worth noting, perhaps, that "You're Sixteen" begins with the bit where Ringo would single out an old granny from the crowd, bring her up on stage, and announce she was 16 and sing to her, something that Ringo (thankfully) soon realized was embarrassing at best and creepy at worst and he cut it from his future acts.

This will be the last time we visit George Harrison in this project, as we finally reach his final project in life, the 2002 album Brainwashed. I did get this in 2002 (or maybe in 2003, at the latest) and, while it is no Cloud Nine, and it's sad George did not have one more Cloud Nine-level album left in him, this is still a worthy contribution to his catalog. Although some songs are forgettable, and "Brainwashed" is a return to the cynical paranoid side of George that has cropped up ever since "Taxman," there is some good stuff here including "Rising Sun," "Stuck Inside a Cloud," and "Never Get Over You." "Any Road" is the second best song on the album, but my favorite is another cover song, and perhaps George's oldest cover song ever, "Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea." It's fun, engaging, and remarkably memorable -- sort of like George always was, at his best.

What is there to say about Paul's Back in the World Live album? There is no new material here, nor even any new arrangements on songs that I noticed. It's interesting to hear how Paul ended some songs in concert, particularly "Hey Jude." But I'm going to share "Freedom" here because I didn't earlier when it came up under Driving Rain.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loW1binvJ7A&list=PLu3OmtA_M134jBn7fdezkvpkYtH1D0QB_&index=27

Which brings us back to Ringo (from now on it will only be the two of them) and Ringo Rama. It's off to a solid start with "Eye to Eye," Ringo's strongest new song since "Don't Go Where the Road Don't Go." Other songs are more hit than miss. "Missouri Loves Company" is nothing but something to hang a pun on. "Instant Amnesia" does interesting things, veering into different types of songs and seems to be either a tribute or a rebuttal to "Instant Karma" -- I can't figure out which, but it's a song worth thinking about. "Imagine Me There" seems to be a more straightforward tribute to John, which actually makes it less interesting. "Never Without You" is a tribute song to George, but is stronger for its universal application; it could really be Ringo comforting anyone they won't be forgotten, minus the few subtle George references. 

I didn't hear it, but "Memphis In Your Mind" allegedly has a recording of Roy Orbison's famous growl in it, making it the last posthumous song to feature Roy, but it doesn't impress me beyond that (plus, despite what I read, I think the growl is really in the bonus track song "I'm Home" -- which also doesn't impress me other than the growl). 

"I Think Therefore I Rock N Roll" is not a deep song (despite its title) and doesn't really try to be, but is just good ol' fashioned rock n' roll. "Trippin' on My Own Tears" doesn't do anything for me. "Write One for Me" is a curious song, switching between Ringo and Willie Nelson mid-song for no real reason and sadly highlights how much better Willie sings that Ringo. "Love First, Ask Questions Later" appeals to me maybe more than it deserves to; it's just a pleasant, easy rocker with a nice message. "Elizabeth Reigns" is a weird song that, similar to "Instant Amnesia," could be honoring or mocking its inspiration and I can't tell. "English Garden" is a remarkable little song, the first one to feature one of the Beatles' dogs on it, and the first new song to segue into one of the other Beatles' songs -- the short rendition of "Let 'em In" in mid-song is the longest cover of a Beatles song by another Beatle up to this point. Then, again in mid-song, the song stops and restarts as a different-sounding song, similar to the trick he used in "Instant Amnesia." 

The bonus track "Ok Ray" is a lot of fun and a good rocker.  

As tempted as I am to pick "Instant Amnesia," "English Garden," or even "Never Without You" as my song to share off this album, I gotta go with my first choice, "Eye to Eye" --    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8UAD4Vq-U3Q&list=PLlKu0fStJqQxM9P-Mm7F3sSD08OmRToAe&index=1 


   

Monday, August 9, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - part 13

I'm amused now to think that, when I heard McCartney II, I thought that was Paul's experimental phase. I was completely unaware of his pseudo-anonymous albums, where he called himself "The Fireman." Now I've listened to some of Strawberries Oceans Ships Forests (which I listened to out of order, having to jump back to 1993 for) and all of Rushes (the 1998 sequel album) and...well...it's very experimental stuff. Some of Rushes is almost not terrible, elevating it above John's and George's experimental albums, but that's really not saying much.

Which brings us back to Ringo. VH1 Storytellers: Ringo Starr, was a TV special turned into a "best of" album, with the added bonus that Ringo introduces each song with a humorous anecdote about that song. It's fun to listen to the stories and makes me wish more Best of albums had this kind of framing device.

Which, like a ping pong game, brings us back to Paul. In 1999 -- completely unknown to me at the time -- Paul came out with Run Devil Run, a really fun albums of rock n' roll covers. I've talked before about how much I love it when the Beatles, together or alone, cover their nostalgic, favorite rockers because they seem to be having the most fun when they're doing this. This album has several surprises -- apparently, Paul wrote three original songs that feel like rock n' roll oldies and hid them in the album so they would seem like covers. Surprisingly, the best song on the album is the most obscure oldie -- the 1958 skiffle song, transformed into a slower, haunting piece by Paul, "No Other Baby" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YipnDL3VrCw&list=PLNZ4pVtD8MsEYxFGTbGHJQ5guU7mFUdKZ&index=18 -- but in other cases Paul wisely knew better than to mess with the originals, like his slavish recreation of "Coquette." But there's not a bad song on the album.   

And next we pong back to Ringo for I Wanna Be Santa Claus, the only solo Beatles Christmas album. I don't have access to the full album, but have heard the treacly title track "I Wanna Be Santa Claus," "Come On, Christmas, Christmas Come On" -- a solid rocker, if not overly Christmas-y, and his cover of "The Little Drummer Boy" -- which is no Mormon Tabernacle Choir version (or even Burl Ives version), but seems so appropriate for Ringo that it can be forgiven. 

Paul's Working Classical is his third classical music album and his second best one, after Standing Stone. The highlight of the album is the inclusion of snippets of instrumental versions of some older and newer Paul songs (up through Flaming Pie), and not just with the vocals cut out, but actual new arrangements for different instruments. They sound really nice and, as snippets, they solve a problem a lot of instrumental covers have where, not the entire song really stands out well enough to be enjoyed just for the music, so you lose your place in the song if you're mentally singing along. These snippets highlight just the most iconic-sounding bits from the songs. Unfortunately, the original tracks also sound like they're just snippets, even the ones that kind of ramble on for up to 12 minutes.

From August of 2000, just four months before getting the Beatles' 1 CD for Christmas (I think most of the family gave each other copies, in fact), Paul then came out with Liverpool Sound Collage, yet another of those experimental albums. The first piece, "Plastic Beetle," isn't too bad, and it's kind of fun hearing random noise punctuated by the Beatles just talking and laughing. But "Peter Blake 2000" is just someone saying "Blake," I'm guessing, 2000 times and it was so awful I bailed on listening to the rest.

Which brings me to 2001 - the 21st century, at last! -- and Ringo's The Anthology ...So Far. This is Best of album, with material from the first three All-Starr Band albums, but there is so much extra material here that it feels like I'm listening to something brand new, or at most just similar to the previous albums. There's Ringo covering the songs you expect him to, and people from The Band, The Who, The Eagles, The Guess Who, and Billy Preston performing songs you would expect them to, and then surprises like Peter Frampton covering "Norwegian Wood" and Rick Danko of The Band covering Buddy Holly. Granted, I had to look up the names of everyone on this album other than Ringo, Billy Preston, and Joe Walsh of The Eagles because I'm not an expert on these bands, but I liked everything I heard and I'm sure that, had I been aware of this 3-CD set at the time, I would have snatched it up and fallen head over heels for the All-Starr Band, instead of wondering what that was all about all these years.

Which brings me to the multi-disc CD set (2 instead of 3) that I did get, Wingspan (though I didn't get it right away in 2001, but a few years later). And...well, what is there to say I haven't already said about dream Best of collections for Paul? It doesn't make sense to compile another Best of Wings collection because there's been no new Wings music to add to the last one. Though on the other hand, this is the one I bought and not the previous one, so maybe from a marketing standpoint this did make sense. 

It's also worth pointing out that Wingspan includes a lot of past singles, while I've been sticking to songs that appeared on albums. The weakness of my approach being that it left "Live and Let Die" out of contention.

   

Tuesday, June 29, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - Part 12

Paul's next album wasn't a song of records, but a special 30-minute "episode" of Oobu Joobu. Oobu Joobu was a radio show that Paul did in the early '90s, and the format was part commercial for his recent albums, part sharing new music he was working on, part reminiscing about old favorites and then covering them, part goofy stuff (my favorite: Linda's "Cook of the House" segments, where she talked about how to cook simple things like garlic bread), and part interviews on subjects important to Paul. The album, Ooobu Joobu: Ecology, is mainly that last part, with Paul talking to people about the environment and how we should all be vegetarians. 

I also got detoured into listening to the first nine Ooobu Joobu episodes. Fun! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nHPNcaBxqTo

Okay, time to get back on track, because we're up to Paul's next album, Flaming Pie, and here, again, is where I came in. It's now 1997 -- albums are starting to come out few and far between for our boys -- and I'm 26. By then, I was a big fan of the Band on the Run Wings album, but somehow the rest of Paul's solo career had managed to stay largely off my Radar. And then this came out. 

As ambitious as some earlier albums, Flaming Pie starts off with "The Songs We Were Singing," signaling that we are not in pop song territory anymore and are about to be treated to something more mythic, if not epic. The narrator of "Songs We Were Singing" could live in any century, perhaps a bard of old, about to share stories through song. "The World Tonight" is a companion song, a song about time, but also about something as simple as seeing someone special to you and how that makes you feel. Following that is a step back, though, with "If You Wanna," a much weaker version of "Sitting in the Backseat of My Car." Then we're back on the right track again with "Somedays," a beautiful slow song that is itself a companion song to "The World Tonight," jumping onto the same theme of seeing someone special to you. "Young Boy" is not as strong until it gets to its chorus, which makes up for a lot. Just as we start rocking on "Young Boy," we slide back into soft and beautiful with "Calico Skies." Again, time is a theme of the song, a strong enough theme to carry the whole song, so the sudden anti-war theme that appears in the middle feels tacked on and unnecessary. And all of that is just preamble to "Flaming Pie," Paul's best attempt yet to get into John's head when he was writing nonsense lyrics (though Paul still can't help himself and explains the song in the bridge). And that's just side one!

Side 2 starts gently with the gently moving "Heaven on a Sunday" that ends with one of Paul's many great romantic lines repeated over and over. "Used to Be Bad" is a fun jam piece that shakes things up just before "Souvenir." If most Paul songs are gems (and I would definitely agree with that assessment), then "Souvenir" is one of the diamonds -- a flawless, powerful song like nothing we'd ever heard before. Then we're back to soft and gentle with "Little Willow," a touching tribute song so good Paul has dedicated it to people twice. Then another jam piece, not quite as good as "Used to Be Bad," but "Really Love You" is just another set-up song for the album's other masterpiece -- that's right, this album has two masterpieces -- "Beautiful Night" (that Ringo is backing Paul on both songs makes "Really Love You" feel even more like a warm-up session for "Beautiful Night"). "Beautiful Night" tricks you; it starts out and you think, "oh, it's another gently moving song," but halfway through -- like "Let It Be," it kicks into high gear and becomes the hardest rocker on the album. And then, like pudding dessert at the end of a great dinner, you get "Great Day" at the end, the perfect title to follow "Beautiful Night," and...well, somedays pudding for dessert might seem like a good idea, and other days it doesn't.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPrBJnK751Q

Ringo and His Third All-Starr Band comes next, but I haven't been able to find a recording of this one anywhere, so I have to skip over it. And that takes us back to Paul, with "Standing Stone."

If you've been reading all these posts, you know I mentioned "Standing Stone" earlier, when talking about how disappointing Paul's attempt at opera was. But it's been a few years since then and Paul has put the work into making his first orchestral classical music album perfect. This was perfect timing because, by '97, I was 26 and just starting to get into classical music. I bought the cassette of "Standing Stone" myself as soon as it came out and loved it, particularly the powerful beginning, where the music surges and ebbs, like choppy water before a storm. With this album, Paul proved that there was nothing he couldn't do brilliantly.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQf_FL9rPLA&list=PLQVM4ld7LE3ktyd80mKgaevjnhLLH2rT9&index=2

Ringo continues to impress me, though only now looking back, and apparently the rest of the world wasn't really paying attention when he released "Vertical Man" either. It doesn't start off great, with "One" sounding like Ringo's version of George's "You" (in fact, the song would probably sound better had he replaced "one" with "you" everywhere it occurs in the song, but if he was plagiarizing his old mate, maybe he didn't want to be so obvious about it). "What in the World" is ...just okay, but then things start to explode with the hard rocker "Mindfield" (which, in fact, is a bit too heavy metal towards the end for my liking), and then this is followed up by "King of Broken Hearts." This is a completely new song and not the earlier country song with the same title, but this second act of plagiarism can be forgiven because this song is fantastic -- almost as beautiful as Ringo's masterpiece "Photograph," and probably belongs in any list of his top 5 songs (like "Photograph," George helped him on this song. Hmm...). After that we get a cool cover of "Love Me Do" bookending the title track "Vertical Man" with a cool cover of "Drift Away." "Drift Away" is an ensemble piece, highlighted by a long verse by Tom Petty that makes me wish Tom and Ringo had done much more together. Unfortunately, that's the last of the really good songs on this album, and I begin to understand why Ringo wasn't able to get more traction with this album when I listen to "La De Da," watch the video, and realize this was the song he thought would be a hit. Like too many songs on this album, it's unoriginal, this a country rock updating of Doris Day's "Que Sera Sera," which is even referenced in "La De Da" like its works cited page.   

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VjAq3Nx3S14  


Tuesday, June 8, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - part 11

We're up to Choba B CCCP, Paul's version of John's Rock n' Roll album with a Russian theme to the packaging (the idea was to make it look like an actual Russian-made album bootlegged to the West). I already covered some of these songs in my last post about a dream Beatles triple album of covers. It is an excellent album, also reminiscent of the Unplugged album, in that Paul seems to be having so much fun reliving these classics.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5oZI6z-VkvQ

And next...ugh...what was I thinking? I think to myself as I've listened to the first 18 minutes of Liverpool Oratorio. There's really an hour and a half of this? Now, I like classical music. And -- spoiler -- I like Paul's second classical album, Standing Stones, a lot. But this is his first classical album and it is an at times comically overelaborate opera about growing up in Liverpool. I did say I like classical music, but that does not extend to opera.  I got up to 25 minutes just while writing this and can't believe I've still got over an hour to go...  

...Holy cow, I made it through the whole thing! Yeah, my opinion didn't change much, though I did start to get emotionally invested in the couple when they were fighting. How cliche, though, that having a child brings them back to together.

Thank goodness I got to follow that up with the surprise delight of Ringo's 10th album, Time Takes Time. I had just turned 21 when this came out and solo Ringo albums were entirely off my Radar. This seems to have been true for too many people, many perhaps burnt by his last few more lackluster albums, and unwilling to give him another try. Oh, how they missed out. "Weight of the World" is a good song that kicks off the album right, with an intro that sounds like it came off a Monkees song, that then delves into good, deep lyrics. This and "Don't Know a Thing About Love" have strong drumbeats (obviously) and strong backup vocalists who complement Ringo nicely. I love "Don't Go Where the Road Don't Go," which is extra great because this is one of those rare songs Ringo wrote on his own, possibly making this my favorite Ringo song ever that he penned himself. I'm less enamored with "Golden Blunders" because, okay Ringo, we've all laughed with you before when you made fun of Paul, but if you're mocking "Golden Slumbers" here, I'm not laughing. 

Side B starts strong with "After All These Years," another song with a real driving drumbeat, though the electric guitarwork gets in the way sometimes. "Runaways" starts out really strong with its emergency vehicle sirens and never slows down, though this one relies on the backup singers more than any others. "In a Heart Beat" sports great, romantic lyrics and an interestingly halting delivery. I like how "What Goes Around" ends better than how it begins (the ending keeps repeating, or going around -- har har). Again -- and I'm not saying this is as good as Goodnight Vienna, it's maybe not even in the same class -- but it's a really strong album and makes me sad that the industry and the fans had basically written off Ringo at this point, thinking he didn't have a great album left in him. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmcusR_EXAs

Back to Paul, this time back to doing what he does better, rock music. Off the Ground has some good and familiar songs on it -- "Looking for Changes," "Hope of Deliverance," "Peace in the Neighbourhood," and "C'mon People" -- all George-level preachy, but enjoyably preachy, with "Hope" being particularly fun and bouncy. "I Owe It All to You" is filler for Paul, but this would be A-game material for most writers. A surprise song that never gets air time that I enjoyed was "The Lovers that Never Were." "Get Out of My Way" sounds like an old school rocker, but not a particularly inspired one. "Winedark Open Sea" is one of those songs that I think is almost a good song, but just doesn't quite get there. The real fun one, the song I like to sing along with every chorus, even though the rest of it speeds by so fast I still don't know what the narrative is, is "Biker Like an Icon."  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYwLCquVONU

Back to Ringo, I watched the whole concert that the "Ringo Starr and the All-Star Band Live from Montreux" album was culled from. I didn't think it was as good as the first incarnation of the All-Star Band, even with someone from the Guess Who in it. It was great for me hearing Ringo plug Time Takes Time by doing "Don't Go Where the Road Don't Go Live," but I felt bad for him when he tried to fire up the crowd about it and they failed to react. Am I the only one who loves that song?

You know what, I'm just gonna listen to it again - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EWf9BmM9Y8


  

     


Monday, May 24, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - part 10

Oops, I skipped over The Best of Dark Horse: 1976-1989! This is a very unusual Best of album because it contains three "new" tracks, two previously unreleased songs and one from the soundtrack to Lethal Weapon 2 (which I didn't know about, as I've never watched that movie). "Poor Little Girl" sounds very familiar, as George clearly took it apart and reassembled it as "Fish on the Sand" on the Cloud Nine album. "Cockamamie Business" and "Cheer Down" don't impress me much; "CB" is George in his "old man yelling at kids in his yard" mode that we'll hear more of on his posthumous album Brainwashed, and "Cheer Down" is a lot of harsh electric guitar without much substance.

Now I have to try the same technique with George that I did with Paul and Ringo. What would my Best of George album sound like, if it was one song out of every eight? It is SO hard to leave out any of the best from All Things Must Pass, but it would be...

Let It Down
All Things Must Pass
Isn't It a Pity (version 2)
Give Me Love
Bye Bye Love (ha, I really like the joke of putting those back-to-back!)
Dark Horse
Tired of Midnight Blue (but only to fill the slot, it isn't otherwise good enough for this dream album)
Crackerbox Palace
Blow Away
All Those Years Ago
Hong Kong Blues
Cloud Nine
When We Was Fab
Got My Mind Set On You (interesting that there are three covers on this Best of album)

That's 14 songs -- far smaller than the two-disc album I compiled for Paul's Best of dream album. But it's a good collection!

Jumping back ahead in time....Travelling Wilburys Vol. 3 is a little sad to listen to for several reasons. There was never (officially) a vol. 2 and will never be a vol. 4. We have now, since Petty passed, lost a higher percentage of Wilburys than we've lost Beatles. And this album was not as good as the first one, and probably could never have been without Roy on it. As a tribute to the camaraderie they shared with Roy (it's dedicated to "Lefty," the Wilbury "character" Roy played), it is not bad at all. There is nothing close to as good as "End of the Line" here, but there is nothing as bad as "Tweeter and the Monkey Man" here either. "She's My Baby" is a hard rocker that seems to kick off the album strongly, though the lyrics don't hold up well to repeat listening. "Inside Out" is a much more solid song. "If You Belonged to Me" is above average. "Poor House" is a delightfully retro song that feels like a cover of an oldie, but isn't. "Wilbury Twist" is the strongest song on side B, but "You Took My Breath Away" is a solid second place and "New Blue Moon" is also above average.

The video for "Wilbury Twist" is one of those fun, star-studded affairs, with the highlight of this being one of the last acting roles of John Candy, plus fun performances by Cheech Marin and George's old buddy Eric Idle - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Vs1dmoKAEc

 Next up is Paul's Unplugged: the Official Bootleg. And I vaguely recall being aware this was going to be a special on MTV at the time, but I blew it off because I wasn't a big fan of Paul's solo work yet in 1991, just as I was turning 20. Now I know this is some fabulous stuff, combining a Best of compilation of his Beatles work and solo work with some covers of oldies he's never released anywhere else before.

A while back, I had exchanged comments with a Facebook friend about what a shame it was the Beatles never did a triple album just of covers, as they clearly knew enough good material to fill one. Of course, the early Beatles album material is half covers, so we do have that, but I'm wondering now what a triple album more like John's Rock n' Roll album would have sounded like. This is a dream compilation of covers from their solo careers, plus Live at the BBC and Beatles Anthology Vol. 1. Oh man, this would have sounded so sweet...

Side 1
Love Is Strange
Kansas City
Lucille
I'm Gonna Be a Wheel Someday
That's All Right (Mama)
Just Because

Side 2
Midnight Special
Bye-Bye Love
Got My Mind Set on You
Be-Bop-a-Lula
Ain't That a Shame
Peggy Sue

Side 3
Bony Maronie
Ya Ya
Angel Baby
To Know Her Is to Love Her
Hound Dog
Young Blood

Side 4
Some Other Guy
Soldier of Love
Crying, Waiting, Hoping
Long Tall Sally
Memphis, Tennessee
Nothin' Shakin'

Side 5
The Hippy Hippy Shake
Glad All Over
I Just Don't Understand
So How Come (No One Loves Me)
Matchbox
Slow Down

Side 6
Searchin'
Three Cool Cats
The Sheik of Araby
How Do You Do It
Leave My Kitten All Alone
Shout

 

Sunday, April 25, 2021

Reviewing the Solo Beatles Albums in Order - part 8

Live in New York City is a live album of John and Yoko performing, thankfully concentrating on John and leaving out some Yoko songs from the concert, including that "Prison" song which I unfortunately heard because I watched the video rather than limiting myself to the record tracks (ugh, I had that stuck in my head like an "ear worm" after listening to it again, though!). It's essentially a best of album, but there is one new cover -- "Hound Dog" -- that makes you wish the Beatles had not been so respectful of the "king" and recorded more Elvis covers. But then Yoko starts screeching over it and -- sigh, even if she had made dog noises it would have made more sense than her screeching. 

Press to Play was a Paul album that had completely escaped my notice all this time. It's not going to become one of my favorites; there are no real winners on this album, but there are certainly good ones here. I really like the bluesy rock of "Stranglehold," even if I'm normally not a fan of horns on rock n' roll songs (this is extra rare because I'm so often not impressed with the first songs on Beatles solo albums). I love it while I'm listening to it, but unfortunately it's not a catchy tune; 10 minutes later, I can't remember the tune anymore, and I've listened to it several times now. I know it's been awhile since Paul's done a medley and maybe thought he was due, but...is "Good Time Coming/Feel the Sun" really a medley, or just talking leading into the next song? Speaking of talking, I really like the chorus on "Talk More Talk," but the rest of it is pretty weak and longer than it deserves to be -- I also don't like all the actual talking in it, even though I get that is the point of the song.   "Footprints" is easy listening, maybe too easy. I like the instruments on it, but the effect of the song is calming as Muzak. "Only Love Remains" starts similar, but kicks it up a notch mid-song, becoming catchier, and has a simple but more obvious message.  "Press" has an '80s dance song vibe similar to "Say Say Say," but full of playful references to physical contact. I do not get why Oklahoma gets two mentions in the song, unless Paul was just lazily filling beats. Not my favorite song on the album, but the music video was nice. The same lazy beat-filling happens on "Pretty Little Head," where there's really no lyrical reason for the "Ursa Major, Ursa Minor" refrain; the song isn't even about constellations -- though it sounds like it would be a better song if it was. "Angry" starts out promising -- ooo, we haven't had a real rocker from Paul in awhile! But then it doesn't really go anywhere...sort of like being angry doesn't really get you anywhere...could that have been intentional?

"Spies Like Us" isn't actually on that album, but it sometimes gets lumped in with it. I haven't heard it in a long time. I remembered liking it, and the movie, way back then, but it doesn't hold up now, sounding like it's trying too hard to be "Live and Let Die." So I'm going to share "Stranglehold" with you, in the hopes that maybe this time I'll remember the tune 10 minutes later!  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxH6Kgul-Ss&list=PLNZ4pVtD8MsGjXbimbkOcDViYu_YP5PBK&index=1

Menlove Avenue is a real treat I didn't know existed; a sort of 'John Lennon Anthology' with all previously unreleased material. By an interesting coincidence, just the day before I had heard "Rock and Roll People" on the Sirius XM Beatles Channel and wondered, where did this come from? Right here. "Here We Go Again" and "Rock and Roll People" are both good rockers, but the covers of "Angel Baby" and "To Know Her Is to Love Her" are just amazing (and the version of the latter is even better on Beatles Anthology vol. 1; it's a shame it was not on an album for so long!) -- and make me wish his earlier album, Rock n' Roll, had been a double album to include more of this magic. Side B is not as magical; it's all variants of tunes from the Walls and Bridges album. All good stuff, but somehow John's own music just isn't as satisfying as when he's belting out classics; it seems to be done with more love for songs he grew up with than for his own material. Here's my favorite version of "To Know Her Is to Love Her" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzUKcn5auuU

And now, this is where I came in. I grew up with the Beatles music from before I was born, not the solo albums they were putting out at the time -- until George's Cloud Nine. It was the creative music video for "Got My Mind Set on You" that sucked me in; I still remember the pizza place in Batavia I was at with my dad and sister when I saw this on the television there, and suddenly I couldn't ignore the solo Beatles anymore. I asked for a copy of the cassette tape version for Christmas. I now understand that Jeff Lynne was instrumental in helping George get his groove back, his love for the music. "Cloud Nine" is a good song like we hadn't had from him in awhile. "When We Was Fab" is a great song. The rest of the songs are filler -- but all good filler. And here's that video that so wowed me when I was 16 -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_71w4UA2Oxo. Still such a rocker. Ooo, I didn't know this was a cover song until writing this!

Next up is All the Best, yet another "best of" album from Paul. But a lazily made one, as it mostly duplicates the previous "best of" Wings compilation. A side game in this project has been rethinking the "best of" albums. Could I have done better? By this time, there were about 170 post-Beatles Paul songs, not counting variations on the same ones. To pare it down to 20 - no, let's make it 24 songs -- that's 1 song for every 8. What would that album look like? Arranged in chronological order, one song from every eight in a row, they would be:

"Every Night"
"Maybe I'm Amazed"
"Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey"
"The Back Seat of My Car"
"Tomorrow"
"My Love"
"Jet"
"Let Me Roll It"
"Magneto and Titanium Man"
"Call Me Back Again"
"Silly Love Songs"
"Warm and Beautiful"
"With a Little Luck"
"Mull of Kintyre"
"Arrow through Me"
"Daytime Nighttime Suffering"
"Waterfalls"
"Goodnight Tonight"
"Ballroom Dancing"
"Pipes of Peace"
"We All Stand Together"
"Simple As That"
"No More Lonely Nights"
"Press"




Monday, March 29, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - part 7

Gone Troppo must have seemed like George's swan song in 1982, to people unaware of how his musical career would rebound at the end of the '80s. It's not terrible; it's not Extra Texture. There are no great songs here, but "That's the Way It Goes" is pleasantly memorable, "I Really Love You" feels like an unearthed classic from the 1950s (it's not, but it's close -- I read later this is a cover of a 1961 song), "Gone Troppo" is far catchier than it has any business being, and "Dream Away" and "Circles" are both pretty good -- the latter apparently being yet another one of those tunes he had pitched to the Beatles that John and Paul shot down -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPLer5cehdM&list=PLYq_mcte9NvC5JKi3U-lI8H-iTAJw5oAm&index=10.

I was really into comic books and this "new" thing called Dungeons & Dragons when Ringo's Old Wave album came out -- not that I would likely have encountered the album if 12-year old me was looking for it, as Ringo was apparently having some crazy trouble finding a record company that didn't think he was washed up at the time and Old Wave had terrible distribution. I like it; "In My Car" is a very Paul-like song, "Hopeless" has the negativity of an early John song, "Alibi" sounds like country but in a good way. "She's about a Mover" is a cover that starts out really strong, but gets lost in its Dixieland middle. "Picture Show Life" feels like something Tom Petty would later put on Full Moon Fever. "As Far As We Can Go" is strangely drums-less, in both versions -- I read later that the version on the album had its backing track entirely redone by The Eagles' Joe Walsh, and I think it was a mistake; I much prefer it with strings -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YlDcg2sSPK8&list=PLZCDbeZmzy0PZ_3ksv1PGeb1CxbAE--2p&index=11

I'm more familiar with Paul's next album, Pipes of Peace, than any of the other albums I've sampled lately, but even this one I've never heard all the way through. "Pipes of Peace" is a good song. I do not like "Say Say Say" because of Michael Jackson. These songs I already knew. "The Other Me" was a surprise, sounding very much like the sort of reflective songs Paul has done on his most recent albums. "Keep Under Cover" is not a bad song, but is more of a movie soundtrack-type song, foreshadowing the upcoming "Spies Like Us." I honestly can't decide if I like "The Man" -- there are things I like and dislike about it. "Sweetest Little Show" is one of those almost-good songs that maybe just needed a little more work on it. "Average Person" is an eccentric, more-upbeat sequel to "Eleanor Rigby" thematically, while sounding more like "Rock Show." Two bonus songs not found on the original album need mention here -- one is "We All Stand Together," the song written for the animated Rupert short that I saw aired on Nickelodeon way back then, and "Simple As That," which is a great song with a unique sound and could have been my favorite song on this album, but was released on a charity album instead -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=klPJzmflOrc&list=PLi_eUMd6th2K4IEcV6EOomA6sjOzNq3EH&index=15. Nice of Paul to give the best away to charity! 

Bonus link: the Rupert cartoon! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a1ZLpqhdm2w

Anyone who's been following these posts knows what I think of Yoko Ono, but I'll say this for her -- she probably would have made more money releasing Milk and Honey right after John's death, but she waited a respectful four years before releasing this posthumous album (although it's possible she simply thought it would have more nostalgia value later). Like Double Fantasy, it is marred with Yoko songs as every other piece on the album, almost all of which is garbage, though "Let Me Count the Ways" is the most normal among them. This album's best track is, of course, "Nobody Told Me" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R1bV8gOvJAo&list=PLA2-nXsHvm3LeXmsIIBPpZoAXr09Om8I2&index=6 -- though "I'm Stepping Out" is a pretty good dance song too. 

Give My Regards to Broad Street was a difficult thing to review. Do I treat it as a movie and rewatch the movie? Is only the soundtrack important? What about incidental music on the soundtrack, or do I just focus on the songs? And then, do I focus on just the three new songs, or treat this as a best of album? Because it's kind of all of the above. "No More Lonely Nights" is definitely the highlight here, being the best new song, and there's really no surprise there. The Beatles covers are tricky. On one hand, it's always fun listening to variants on the old standards, but a true fan is always going to say the original Beatles songs are better, and someone who's not a true fan may feel that the orchestral arrangements try to give the songs a gravitas they don't warrant. Me, I'm a sucker for strings and I really like the string arrangement on "For No One" -- and I love the original. It may also be worth noting that the starting words to "Here There and Everywhere" are different, perhaps changing the meaning of the song. The extended version of "Eleanor Rigby," combined with "Eleanor's Dream," is nice, though "Dream," at nine minutes, might need to be that long for the movie, but feels long for the soundtrack. "Good Night Princess," an instrumental, feels like it came straight from a 1930s film.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y3Xn9A4Negk&list=PLNZ4pVtD8MsH3RYU5EP2SE37gb4EhLA5S&index=16

 

Sunday, March 28, 2021

GaryCon XIII Post-Con Report

I attended GaryCon XIII virtually these past four days. I also worked two of those same days, so it wasn't a full convention for me. 

Thursday
Day 1, slot 1 of GaryCon was my first of three games I was running over Zoom. It was the classic AD&D module A3 Assault on the Aerie of the Slave Lords - part 1 (getting to Suderham through the salt mines). I had eight players sign-up and eight players show, which was a great start. After three hard-fought battles, the last two just barely won, the Slave Lord Hunters succeeded in clearing their way through the salt mines.

Some fun notes about our game session:

Elwita the Dwarf was played by Jonathan, the player who had been in my Lost Caverns of Tsojconth/Tsojcanth game at virtual GenCon last year.

Karraway had a Scroll of Remove Fear, but was the only member of the party affected by Fear (and while paralyzed). He cast almost none of his spells (so he has them for next time), and was the PC who came closest to dying.

I wasn't keeping track of Blodgett's Strength loss from those shadows, but since he started at a 9, he must have been very feeble by the end of that fight. Between that and being held and chewed on by the storoper, he was likely the second closest to dying.

When we were turning shadows at the end, we forgot that Eljayess was also a cleric! Eljayess was played by Neil Christiansen, one of the early players in the Hobby Shop Dungeon campaign, who also taught us that Eljayess stands for LJS, Larry J. Schick's initials!

We also learned that Phanstern's name was combined from two Shakespearean characters, which made it, coincidentally, even more apropos that I had replaced the "to be read out loud to the players" prologue for the adventure with one based on the famous "O for a muse of fire" prologue from Henry V.  

Despite being forewarned that limited resource management was going to be critical to surviving both rounds, the spellcasters Delgath and Phanstern had to burn though a lot of spells, and in Phanstern's case all but two spells!

Design Notes (SPOILERS, if you ever plan to play this as-is!)

I took the final encounter, dissembled it, and spread it around. Wimpell Frump, instead of being the powerful illusionist masquerading as Yeenoghu, became Wimpell Frump the slave accountant (and minor illusionist, not that he ever got a chance to cast a spell) the PCs had encountered first. Instead of being an illusion of an ankylosaur (and how would Frump even know what one looks like...?), the ankylosaur became real, their second encounter, and what I thought was a logical explanation for the Earth Dragon alluded to later in the module.

As written, the salt mine had gnoll guards, but they aren't guarding any prisoners/slaves/miners, so I did add those throughout and the PCs heard some of them murmuring from the gnoll lair they didn't visit. As-is, the gnolls aren't supposed to reinforce each other. I planned on having the gnolls from one room come and aid the other, but could not have anticipated that my players would lure one group (although unintentionally) back into the tunnel with them, so they would encounter both groups in the tunnel -- probably the toughest way to fight that joint encounter you could have possibly chosen.

As-is, the map railroads you through every encounter area one after another; I shook up the map and added tunnels that crisscrossed and let them take the rooms out of order or miss some altogether (plus I had added a few more!). By then I thought Wimpell would have been able to escape, but they were way too good at keeping him prisoner.

The storoper is supposed to be able to inject that paralyzing poison that makes it look like it petrified you, with no save, twice only -- but as the storoper's most interesting attack form, I decided to ignore that limitation. To balance it, I took away how you fight for the storoper after the initial paralysis wears off. Wandering aimlessly is only supposed to happen after the storoper dies, but moving it up made the "heh heh, you're stoned, guys" joke more obvious. This battle nearly did in the party, with over half the party wandering around "stoned" before it was over.

Yeenoghu and his attendant gnolls and ghouls were illusions in the original version, but the gnolls needed a leader better than Frump, so I invented Goom the Gnoll King, a gnoll 8th level fighter, with his 3 HD gnoll vassals. As the spawn of Yeenoghu, he could save vs. spells as if a magic-user and summon his vassals' shadows (the ghouls got a little upgraded). I figured the PC clerics would turn the shadows easily. Oops! It turned out to be a very hard battle, only barely won.

Friday
This was my one all-play day, with no events I was running. And, ...well, let's take them one at a time.

In slot 1, I was supposed to play "Lowdown in Highport," an original AD&D prequel adventure to the Slave Lords modules, which seemed highly apropos for me to play. However, it was run over a new site called Fantasy Grounds, and I could not get my computer to play any sound from that site. This had happened to me before, last year, when I tried playing a game over Discord, so I was ready with backup this time and tried listening over a laptop -- but I could not get sound to work over that device either! The DM did try cutting and pasting descriptions into the chat for me, but I couldn't interact with the setting at all, so I quit in frustration. Not a good start to the day -- and NOT a good first impression of Fantasy Grounds!

In slot 2, I played another original adventure (this one for Swords & Wizardry) called "Green Fire," over Skype. Skype worked okay, but it seemed to lag more than Zoom. It was fun playing a magic-user with a 5 Charisma and everyone was very appreciative of me choosing to memorize Strength to boost the already-strongest fighter in the party. The scenario was extremely simple -- travel away from the village and find a hut that a seemingly endless number of goblins pour out of and kill them until the time runs out and our DM had a very slow, leisurely pace to him. 

To be fair, it's possible that we weren't supposed to do that; I had suspected from the start that we were supposed to interrogate the prisoners in the village and find out more information of stuff to do in-town, and that the House of Endless Goblin Spawning was a red herring that got retconned into the end encounter after my vote was overruled by the party, who all wanted to head straight after the goblins. Either way, the point of the scenario seemed to be to introduce us to the DM's campaign setting, in the hope that we would want to revisit it.

Slot 3 of day 2 of GaryCon was Tim Kask's "The Wheel of Blame." Because of technical difficulties, it started over an hour late, but still ended on time.  One of the thrills of GaryCon is the chance to play with the Old Guard, the chance to walk back in time and see what it would have been like to game with them in the Early Days. 

But. 

But....What Tim ran was five unconnected escape rooms, and I hate escape rooms. Now, some of the time he was obviously flexible about what the escape was, but other times he was more adamant that we had to think of his way or we weren't getting out.  Interestingly, I played with my afternoon DM, from "Green Fire," so that was quite the coincidence. The best part was the few minutes I got to talk to Tim one-on-one after everyone else left.

Saturday
Slot "1" was not a real GaryCon event -- I ran my OD&D campaign's 20th session, wherein the Company of the White Oak (all 1st-4th level PCs) started exploring the Temple of Elemental Evil! Brigands were fought, treasure was found, and an attack on the Town of Hommlet was averted!

Slot 2 was part 2 of the Assault on the Aerie of the Slave Lords. Seven players (not all the same ones as last time, plus some new ones) explored Suderham, the middle third of the adventure that is all city-based. I had planned on tweaking Suderham, as I had the dungeon parts, but I had run out of time to do so and had to run this part as-is. Well, mostly as-is; getting into the city proved more interesting, as we roleplayed out the part only summarized in the module, where they capture some merchants and then pretended to be the drivers and guards working for the merchants to get in. Once they were in the city, the players, all or almost all of whom knew the adventure already, tried real hard not to use too much player knowledge, but easily followed the clues to get to the sewer entrance in one of the bawdy houses. And, again, we spent a good amount of time -- what amounted to more than our first hour -- on roleplaying through all this.  

More SPOILERS
When they found the dungeon (and then found it again, because they had overshot the concealed door in room 1 that led to the rest of the dungeon), they had a rough go of it with the flesh golem, which I treated as an almost full-strength flesh golem and not the watered down one found in the module. This sent them fleeing to rest and heal, which was tough on the scenario because it was supposed to be timed and their ability to regain spells was supposed to be limited. I did cop out and gave them some cleric spells back, and then they felt brave enough to go back and tackle my tweaked version of the sewer dungeon. 

They found the secret door that, in the original version routes them straight to the big boss battle, but I detoured them to the minotaur maze, as we had lots of time left. They spent what felt like a lot of time in the minotaur maze; the thief wanted to search every single 10' x 10' square for traps and I had to talk him out of it, for the good of the rest of the night. Things picked up when they found their way out of there. The gelatinous cube trap I kept as-is and that was very deadly. They also encountered some extra encounter areas I had added to the scenario, including one that gave them a chance to find a much-needed healing potion -- but of two potions they found, which was the good one? The ranger solved it by mixing them together and drinking both, so it both healed him and made him sick. They dodged the shambling mound in the "Grotto of Terror" by slowing it down with a Slow spell and floating across the water. Because we were now running out of time, I skipped the last encounter areas and got them to the final big boss battle.

As written, this was meant to be the Big Boss Battle of all big boss battles, and yet I had run this fight with the Slave Lords before and they always lose. So I fixed things -- the five figures on the thrones were the hirelings of the real slave lords, all half the level on the original versions. The two sides lobbed fireballs at each other first thing and the party's fireball did more harm, killing or knocking out three of the fake slave lords right off the bat, while only two of the party were seriously hurt. Captain Feetla and Brother Milerjoi went down in round three. Thinking it was all over, the PCs went around decapitating their foes and looting treasure.

And then the first of the REAL Slave Lords started arriving. Lord Feletheus, for example, was a 9th level fighter with a -5 AC, 77 hp, and hit the ranger with a Rod of Smiting, held with Gauntlets of Ogre Power, and struck her dead in one hit, with maximum damage -- 39 points. NOW the Slave Lords were going to be a tough fight!

The real Nerelas the Assassin teleported into the room, invisible (they could tell because magic chessboard squares were serving as teleportals in the room and lit up when used; the chessboard had become a repeating motif in my tweaked version). It was getting late, I was getting tired and making mistakes and, as the party's magic-user looted the fake Mordrammo, I accidentally read off the real Mordrammo's long list of magic items to him, then said, "Oops -- that's the real Mordrammo who's coming..." This only helped to make them very afraid. Overwhelmed, they distracted Feletheus and Nerelas with an illusion and fled up the stairs -- straight into waiting cages. Trapped! And ready for the Dungeon of the Slave Lords, just the way the module was meant to end. 

Everyone had stayed 30 minutes late so we could wrap up the whole thing. I was told that my version of the ending was better than the published version -- high praise indeed!

Sunday
Day 4 had one event today, Hideouts & Hoodlums: Assault on the Aerie of the Nazi Slavers -- taking what I ran using D&D and updating it to 1945, the Ore Mountains on the German-Czech border. 

Although H&H had done well at GaryCon two years in the past, it was not popular this time; only three people signed up and two showed to play. Those two were Lee and Timothy LeMaster, both experienced with H&H. I gave them the option of two heroes each, but they each wanted to play only one character. To try to balance things, I gave each of them two really good healing pills they could take in a pinch. They chose Superman (the Czech version of Superman) and Golden Guide, a mysteryman (woman, actually). 

Both this and my AD&D version of the scenario began with a Wimpell Frump stand-in being encountered first thing in the adventure, but this time the LeMaster's missed the fact that Wimpell (or Vlastimil here) was leaving them but not heading back towards the camp. Missing the shortcut, they planned a direct assault on the German-controlled Czech mine camp outside the mine entrance, with just one big diversion for cover. It used up their one stick of dynamite, but it was a very big distraction when it blew up the ammunition supply point building. Superman wrecked them through the fence and they dashed into the main building, fighting their way past guards to get to the bridge from that building's tower that led to the ancient gatehouse that was the mine's entrance. They had to fight their way past a dozen armed guards, eating up some of the superhero's better (but not best) powers, and even then I was already going easy on them, having planned on their being twice that many defenders at the gatehouse if the heroes tried this direct route. 

Once in the mines, it was more like a straight D&D session, with them exploring two caves, running into small guard patrols in two of them (as originally planned). Superman burnt through more powers and Golden Guide had terrible luck with her guns jamming a lot, but they finally found their way to the big boss battle. This time, King Goom was replaced by Vlastimil, an ultra-mad scientist, his Nazi lieutenant, six bestial Nazis (oh yeah, in this version, the guards weren't gnolls, but they had been surgically altered to be more animalistic and 2 HD), plus six more that had been fully transformed fully into beast-men -- ghouls -- and there was a three-man crew manning a Panzer II tank in the room. The chamber was no longer an audience chamber, but had been converted into a mad scientist's laboratory (or at least the back half had). 

They played pretty smart, trying to wreck the tank (with the superhero's wrecking things) and shooting at the lab equipment to blow it up. But they were badly outnumbered and the ghouls paralyzed Superman. Golden Guide led a lot of their opponents away, got them into a fight with miners the heroes had liberated earlier, then left the miners to get slaughtered as she doubled back to save Superman. By now, Superman was being hauled away down an escape tunnel, kept chloroformed by Vlastimil and his lieutenant. Golden Guide caught up and, while a firefight went on between Golden Guide and the lieutenant, Superman recovered and broke the man's gun. But then Vlastimil used a hypno-monocle to charm Superman and set the two heroes against each other! Golden Guide kept dodging to stay alive until it wore off, but the two leaders had escaped ahead of them to warn the Slave Lords in Dresden...and there we stopped, just 15 minutes over our time slot. They said they want to play the rest some time. If they get some help next time, I won't have to fudge so much to keep things easy for them!

And now GaryCon is done for another year. It was a great experience, but really more for the games I ran for the players I had, not the games I played. I'm glad I get the opportunity to play other people's games, but I don't think I'd ever do a campaign again as a player only, just in case. 

Addendum: But wait -- it still wasn't over! At 7, there was 
Jay Scott
's Twitch show, which was a who's who of famous Greytalkers! 
Anna Meyer
, who remapped the Flannaess! 
Denis Tetreault
, who remapped the City of Greyhawk! 
Mike Bridges
, who drew the World of Greyhawk! 
Allan T. Grohe Jr.
, seen by many as the ultimate authority on Castle Greyhawk and Old School publisher! Eric Boyd and Erik Mona, who parlayed their early entry into Internet fandom into long publishing careers that extended well beyond Greyhawk! And 
Gary Holian
, who practically invented Greyhawk fandom online!

And that still wasn't the end because, while I was watching the show, 
Arch Zenopus
 messaged Facebook and revealed that there were open spaces in "Temple of Diklah and the Helm of Valasdum," the second part of the GenCon IX Dungeons, and it was starting soon!! Having long owned it but never played it, I longed to see if my assessment of how much of that tournament needed a complete overhaul was accurate. Casting the Twitch show and my laundry duties for the evening aside I jumped in! And I daresay my dwarven king was vital to keeping the game entertaining, as inexperienced gamers in the group slowed us down in a railroad of encounter areas that betrayed the primitive game design skills developed by 1976, with just occasional flashes of ingenuity. Everyone was half-asleep by the time we reached the big boss battle with the lich and, as the game dragged on past midnight, I was not prepared to reach 12:30 still in the game, so I curtly bailed on them just as the lich and two golems had two members of the party cornered!

Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums in Order - part 6

And things don't get better from here, since Paul follows it with McCartney II. This album feels like Paul just discovered John and George did experimental electronic records years ago so he cobbled together his own version to catch up. "Coming Up" has been re-recorded by Paul since and is a good song, but you wouldn't know it from the original version, with its Alvin & the Chipmunks-like refrain. "Temporary Secretary" is ...comedy? A few years back I got to finally see Paul in concert and was floored when he actually performed "Temporary Secretary" as part of the show. He must like it! "Waterfalls," if you listen closely to the lyrics, could be mistaken for a joke song too. There are two verses that seem like just placeholders (don't go ...chasing polar bears? What?), but the first verse and the refrain and the melody are so gorgeous that these flaws can be overlooked; "Waterfalls" is the one gem on this album -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbvdQBz65tM -- and I was so pleased he performed this one too! Side B is a complete waste, though "Bogey Music" might have been one of his competent retro songs had he not cranked the reverb up to 11.  

John Lennon's Double Fantasy has high highs and low lows, and you'll never guess who's doing the vocals on each of them. Yes, it's a "double fantasy" because Yoko gets just as many songs as John and, true to form, most of hers are pathetic exercises in egoism masquerading as art -- with one exception, "Yes, I'm Your Angel" is a simple, retro song she sings with her normal voice instead of her screechy obnoxious voice.  That doesn't make it good, but it's ...actually not bad. They also try to make this synergy between the songs, so that Yoko's songs tie in to the John song before it, or answers one of John's earlier songs on the album. John, meanwhile, produces the best songs of his solo career, "Beautiful Boy" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lt3IOdDE5iA -- , "Watching the Wheels," and "Woman." With nothing but these three songs on it, no filler, this would still be a must-have album. "Starting Over" and "Dear Yoko" are B-grade songs, either deep or catchy, but neither both.    

How lucky we are that we got this one last album from him. John was, in life, a terrible person on so many levels, but as a musician he truly achieved greatness. 

I never hear anyone say George Harrison's Somewhere in England is their favorite album, but it is indeed a good album. "All Those Years Ago" is, of course, the big hit on this album and an excellent song -- basically a Beatles song in almost every sense, with all three remaining Beatles on it, and John there at least in spirit. "Unconsciousness Rules" is apparently seen as such a slight song that it has no Wikipedia entry, but I really like it. "Life Itself" is also good, though I don't seem to like it as much as some critics did. I really thought George wrote "Baltimore Oriole" as a more whimsical sequel to "Blue Jay Way," but apparently I was way off. That, and "Hong Kong Blues," are covers of Hoagy Carmichael songs. Of the two of them, "Hong Kong Blues" is the one I like. I think side B is even stronger than side A; there's not a song I didn't like on side B. None of them are great, but they're all good. There is, apparently, been some effort to overinflate the reputation of the three songs cut from this album and only released years later, but of them, "Lay His Head" and "Sat Singing" are only pretty good, and "Flying Hour" is subpar. The obvious choice for the song to share from this album is still "All Those Years Ago," but since I like to defy expectation, I'm going to go with the extra-catchy "Teardrops" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TN2Sbcu6BN0&list=PLnif9Rfb5AdlIne-lnuIc-XpgkJ26t8nf&index=6 -- instead. 

 Ringo is back to full strength again on Stop and Smell the Roses. Rather than stretch in new directions and challenge us to follow again, Ringo retreats to the familiar territory of fun songs and dishes up the lovely "Wrack My Brain," "Drumming Is My Madness," "Stop and Take the Time to Smell the Roses" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4mcNIqnX_8 -- and an expanded version of "Back Off Boogaloo" that adds a winking Beatles medley into it. Though the rest of the tracks are just of average quality, these four are so enjoyable that I don't understand why this album did not do better. "Attention" was apparently written for Ringo by Paul, but Paul rarely gave out his best material to Ringo and this song is no exception. There are two covers on Side B and one of them, Carl Perkins' "Sure to Fall" has a lot of history with the Beatles and could have been better, but Ringo goes full-on country on this track and the song suffers for it.

Following that new release was a best of album for Ringo, Blast from Your Past. At a brief 10 songs, it was clearly meant to re-whet fans' appetites and leave them wanting more again. By then, it should have been easy to fill a two-disc album with his best songs. "Early 1970" is probably the weakest link on this album, but there's not a bad song to be found here, and most are truly great.

Paul's Tug of War is a pretty good album. "Take It Away" and "Here Today" are great songs. I should probably not like "Ballroom Dancing" as much as I do; it's a retro song, in topic but not style, and specific to something I never experienced. But it's super-catchy and nostalgic for me in a different way, as the filmed segment of this in Give My Regards to Broad Street -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwOxAtnQomM -- is the only part of it I remember watching when this was on cable TV back in the '80s. I probably also like "The Pound Is Sinking" more than it warrants. Is it a silly song with random lyrics, or an anti-capitalistic screed? I can't tell, but I think I like it better thinking of it as the latter. "The Pound Is Sinking" and "Wanderlust" sound so similar, I wonder if they were originally meant to form one of Paul's medleys -- which I think would have added strength to both of them here. What really shocks me is reading about this album afterwards and how it was heralded as Paul's masterpiece and a return to form for him at the time. Sure, it's much better than Back to the Egg, but nothing on here measures up to "Waterfalls" in my estimation. The title track, "Tug of War," does nothing for me and the many duets are just so-so. Kudos to doing one with Carl Perkins -- though, like Ringo covering Carl, it comes across as more country than rock-a-billy -- and "Ebony and Ivory" is too cliched (and I'm not a big Stevie Wonder fan). 


Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums - Part 5

George was understandably upset when the Best of George Harrison album was released and half the songs were Beatles songs. Which begs the question: how hard could it be to come up with 13 great solo Harrison songs by the end of 1976? 

Obviously, the All Things Must Pass album would be well-represented here. The actual album only includes "My Sweet Lord" and "What Is Life." I would include "Isn't It a Pity," "Let It Down," and "All Things Must Pass," even if that does make more than one-third of the album a re-release of All Things Must Pass. "Give Me Love" from Living in the Material World, "Dark Horse" from Dark Horse, and "See Yourself" and "Crackerbox Palace" from Thirty-Three and 1/3 are musts. Dang, still need four more....I guess I would need to include at least one song from each album, so I would add "Bangla-desh" from The Concert of Bangla Desh and "Tired of Midnight Blue" from Extra Texture so those albums are represented. Two more...gee, this is tough!  Sorry, George, but I gotta go back to mine more from All Things Must Pass. "Wah-Wah," "Apple Scruffs," and "The Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp" are better than anything else on the latter albums. There, 14 songs, culling the least from All Things Must Pass and replacing them with the best from the latter albums.

I debated whether or not to listen to concert albums in this project. I'm not generally a fan of them. But Wings over America is a great album. This is where the extended, far superior version of "Maybe I'm Amazed" first comes from. This version of "Call Me Back Again" is superior to the original and this version of "Hi Hi Hi" is more rocking than the original. There are fun variants of the Beatles song "I've Just Seen a Face" and Wings' "Picasso's Last Words." There is a terrific cover of "Go Now" that I have never heard Paul sing before. The only flaw in the album is a new song, "Richard Cory," an attempt at a folk song, that thankfully disappears from all McCartney albums after this (looking this up after the fact, I see it's a cover of a Paul Simon song based on an old poem, but...bleh. You'll never find this on a Best of Paul Simon album either!).  

Goodness, I'm getting sidetracked. While working on this project I discovered the existence of Live! At the Star-Club in Hamburg, Germany. There are 26 songs on this album, some of which would find homes on their early albums, some I recognize from Beatles Live at the BBC, and some I've never heard before! 

I got sidetracked there for awhile, listening to concert tracks and BBC tracks, and a lot of great Beatles music. That made it difficult to go back to solo records and...Ringo the 4th. Not a memorable song on the album and ...ugh... all so disco-y! 

Quick, need to wash it down with "Mull of Kintyre." ...Phew!

But Scouse the Mouse, Ringo's children's album? That was a lot of fun! It's a shame the animated special was never made...and kind of weird that the album was produced before the special. "Scouse's Dream," "Scouse the Mouse," and "I Know a Place," are all breezy fun, enjoyable tunes, while "S.O.S." and "A Mouse Like Me" have some weight to them.

Equally enjoyable is Bad Boy -- man, Ringo was really cranking them out fast, trying for a hit! Well, not the song "Bad Boy" itself, which is more Ringo the 4th-type silliness, but "Who Needs a Heart" is pretty good, "Heart on My Sleeve" is even better, and "Where Did Our Love Go" is a real nice cover. Side B is pretty solid except for "Old Time Relovin'" (Reloving...?), and "A Mouse Like Me" sounds even better as "A Man Like Me," becoming my favorite track on this album - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sO0zN9Axo7g&list=PL7C3C0039597B5677&index=10

Whew, I just listened to Wings Greatest Hits -- twice! It's hard to find any fault with this sterling selection of songs. My only complaints would be that the order of the songs seems very random and they don't fit well next to each other, and this should have been a two-disc album for twice the songs!

George Harrison's next album is George Harrison and it was really nice hearing George get serious about music again. "Blow Away" is a great song. I've liked "Not Guilty" since I heard it on the Beatles Anthology albums -- what a long time to sit on such a good song! I'm also partial to "If You Believe" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xw8rp5RScp8 - I've never heard this one before but it sounds real pretty; love the guitar work on it. In fact, everything on Side B is at least pretty good, what I like to call "one draft away from perfect" songs. 

Now it's back to Paul and, oh dear...Wings Greatest Hits was followed by Back to the Egg? It's been a long time since we got a Wings album full of filler, and such mundane filler that "Getting Closer" and "Arrow through Me," the good songs, sound too good for this album, like they wound up here by accident. To be fair, "Old Siam Sir," would probably make a good instrumental. "Baby's Request," alone on Side B, is promising. But the rest are...some of them are paired-up like mini-medleys, but while Paul has done some beautiful things with medleys in the past, here they feel crudely mashed together. Some of them are barely, or even literally not, even songs. "The Broadcast" seems like it was accidentally recorded over a real song.


   

Friday, January 15, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums - Part 4

It's probably high time I included a disclaimer in this series of posts: I am not writing academically about the albums after doing appropriate research, but recording my observations after listening to them. Occasionally I will look something up after the fact, but this is my purpose here.

We're At the Speed of Sound by Wings, or is the title Wings at the Speed of Sound? The album cover is ambiguous there. In some ways this is the first true Wings album, yet in other ways it isn't...but we'll get to that shortly.

While there is undeniably filler on this album, there are also strong songs like "Let 'em In," "She's My Baby," "Beware My Love," "Silly Love Songs," and "Warm and Beautiful," of which I think "She's My Baby" is the weakest and "Silly Love Songs" is tops. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wh15LOppcWQ

Also -- and here's what makes this such a Wings album -- Paul steps away from the lead microphone three times to let his teammates shine. Including Linda! Though never known for her singing voice, like the old days with Ringo, Paul has crafted a fun song that's not too challenging to sing in "Cook of the House." None of these songs are particularly good, but they are all at least okay, and fulfill a promise Paul had made to them when Wild Life was originally going to be a double album with lead vocal by the others on it. 

Now, there is no other reason Paul would have needed to do this. Remember, until the Beatles, it was not normal for a band to have more than one lead singer! The Beatles had so much star potential that George Martin wisely agreed to let them perform on their early albums as they did on stage, as a true ensemble, and in the process changed the group dynamics of bands for all time. Paul didn't have to go this route; he is, after all, the undeniable star of the band. But did he feel nostalgic, perhaps, for how the Beatles worked...?

Also, let me bring up "Beware My Love" again -- again, not the best song on the album, but certainly unusual; unusual, for Paul, the syrupy romantic, to sing a song about love being dangerous. It could be a gentler sequel to "Live and Let Die," perhaps, or it could be an intentional effort to write something more like his old partners John or George. In John's case, love literally was dangerous, since he was a violent man, while George often sang of love as an overpowering, uncontrollable force. So, while "at the Speed of Sound" suggests rapid movement, perhaps it is backwards, towards his past with the Beatles...?

I am not surprised that Ringo's Rotogravure didn't do well at the time and is largely unknown today. It is an album without any theme or identity, like a Best of album made up of new and less worthy material. Ringo ranges on it from classic rocker to country (of course) to Mexican Mariachi to experimental (the only way I can think to describe "Spooky Weirdness", which just sounds like someone accidentally left a mic running while everyone was taking a break).

"Hey Baby" is a cover that I think is better than the original, but other than that....Anyone who makes it through the rather dull A side will be rewarded by two minor gems on side B. "I'll Still Love You" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMB08K93H6g -- is the best song on the album (I see, later, that George wrote this!) and I enjoyed "Cookin' (in the Kitchen of Love)" (though, I suspect I find this unduly amusing because it reminds me of "Bushes of Love", the Bad Lip Reading song; and this was a John-penned song!). 

Also worth a listen is this recording of George trying to get "I'll Still Love You" to work on his own - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDmVoVPrtRg

George's Thirty Three and 1/3 was a step back in the right direction after the frivolous Extra Texture. We're still not back to him making great albums, but we're almost there because George is taking the music seriously again. "See Yourself" and "Crackerbox Palace" -- are  good songs, and "Dear One," "It's What You Value," and "True Love" are all close to good songs, maybe just one re-write away (Ha, after the fact, I looked this up and found that "True Love" is a cover! Well, I wish he'd done more with it, then). "This Song" is, on first listen, awfully similar to "Northern Song," but the context behind it is the ridiculous court case where George was found guilty of the nonexistent crime of unintentional plagiarism. It seems, whenever George is frustrated by something, you're going to get a bitter song out of it like "Taxman," "Northern Song," or "This Song." 

Did I say he was taking his music more seriously? The video for "Crackerbox Palace" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ac34Khe-fc -- seems to put the lie to that, and yet George is just having fun (and inspired by his new Monty Python friends; watch carefully and you'll see Eric Idle cameo in the video, as well as Batman!) -- but I should have said he was putting more effort into the songs again.

Tuesday, January 12, 2021

Reviewing the Beatles Solo Albums - part 3

Hard to believe that, by the end of '74, George Harrison seemed so out of ideas that he could come up with so little for his Dark Horse album. Leading with an instrumental and two filler songs? "Maya Love" sounds pretty good. "Bye Bye Love" seems like an odd cover, but maybe it just sounds so weird to hear an Everly Brothers song without harmonizing on it. "Ding Dong Ding Dong" is a paper-thin confection, but if you ignore how there's almost nothing to it, the tune is rather catchy. And then, of course, "Dark Horse" is pretty good and the raison d'etre for the album. I prefer this bonus track/earlier version - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqL2PEwq9qM.... Harrison seems to make a habit of layering too much onto his songs, when they sound best with the simplest of arrangements.

I've been looking forward to listening to this one again! I don't own it, but I've grooved to John Lennon's Rock n' Roll album more than once, borrowing it from my library. This is always going to be my favorite Lennon solo album -- no Lennon the Artiste or Lennon the Social Critic or Lennon, Yoko's Stooge in sight -- this is just a guy who loves rock n' roll music, singing rock n' roll music, and you can hear that love in every tune. The only missteps are slowing down "Do You Want to Dance" and "Bony Maronie," which turn out not as good as the originals. Conversely, "Sweet Little Sixteen" is much improved by mixing in the sound of "Little Egypt" by the Coasters. But the one I'm going to share is "Just Because" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQkouyTSKlg... -- which John can't resist waxing nostalgically on before he starts belting it out.

After Ram and Band on the Run, it would be hard for anyone's album to measure up, so it's no surprise that Venus and Mars doesn't quite measure up. But there are no bad songs! The "Venus and Mars" intro and reprise are now becoming familiar features of Beatles and solo Beatles albums, but the reprise comes almost in the middle, defying expectations. "Rock Show" is fun, but more satisfying are the gentle "Love In Song," the retro "You Gave Me the Answer" (Paul was so good at retro), and another rocker, "Letting Go." "Medicine Jar" is the weakest song, and that's only because it's so average. "Spirits of Ancient Egypt" is so goofy that it shouldn't work, but Paul sings it with such earnestness that you can't help but like it. Of all the songs on it, "Call Me Back" is the song I sing most often out loud, it's so amazing that Paul can take anxiety about a phone call, something we can all relate to, and turn it into something so epic. But, of course, I can't not mention "Magneto and Titanium Man!" Paul's tribute to the Marvel Comics work of Jack Kirby is marred only by the fact that Jack Kirby didn't have anything to do with the Titanium Man. And those two villains never worked together, ever. And the crime they're pulling off is just silly. But it's good clean comic book fun! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wq9z7D8HKZo&list=PLrv5a_5drVgT6kEK-hHQYs-UaE9LyM7F-&index=5

So far in my listening project, I've heard two masterpiece albums from Ringo, three from Paul, and one from John and George each, so it got to be pretty difficult getting through George's Extra Texture. I normally write these based on my own impressions without doing any additional reading first, but I did happen to see the comments section on "You" and how some people loved it for its simplicity. And it's true that I did say George was better when he went for sublime without too much over-layering...but there is a line he's crossed here that seems to veer into sheer laziness. I can't even recommend "Tired of Midnight Blue," probably the least bad song on the album, enough to bother linking you to it. Hoping things pick up again soon...

It doesn't seem quite fair to compare "Best of" albums to regular albums, so all I'm going to say about John Lennon's Shaved Fish and Ringo Starr's Blast from Your Past is that they are full of great songs, and Shaved Fish is a terrible name.